Pondering Pick-Ups

By praram, Flickr Creative Commons

I’ve recently started watching How I Met Your Mother on Netflix. In marginally related news, I was browsing Craigslist as research for a blog post, and this all got me thinking about a conversation I had at dinner with a couple of friends last week. We were discussing an experiment we’d conducted where three of us posted dating profiles online. I got easily three times as many messages as the two guys combined. This isn’t surprising; girls are used to being on the receiving end of romantic overtures.

The more I thought about it though — in the context of How I Met Your Mother and creepy Craigslist personal ads — the more I realized I couldn’t remember the last time I’d been straight up asked out in a real life situation. It might actually have been the prom… or by this tiny little gnome of a man I met in New York, who wore a ridiculous hat every day. But in TV Land Ted Mosby is constantly asking girls out in elevators, in bars, at the doctor’s office, etc. I just don’t believe this happens any more, which is funny because a quick perusal of any dating site will turn up hundreds of profiles with guys claiming they just don’t know where to meet women any more.

Meeting people is easy, apparently it’s the asking them out part that’s hard. I don’t think it’s just me, either. I can’t think of any of my female friends who’ve called me up and said, “I was in the produce aisle today and this guy asked me about melons and before I knew it we were having coffee.”

Now, I’ve had plenty of guys in bars buy me drinks or hit on me. Some of them weren’t even obnoxious or drunk. But did any of them muster up the cajones to just say, “Hey can I have your number?” Well, yes, there was one guy at a party but most of them just look confused when, after chatting for an hour, I walk out the door. What is that about?

(Funny story: When my friend and I were in Los Banos, CA making friends with the locals, a super seedy old guy ambushed me by the bathroom and gave me his number. He was easily a foot taller than me, and I probably weighed 20 lbs more than he did. Half his body weight was his abnormally long hair.)

So, as Valentine’s Day approaches, fellas, consider chatting up a lady in the cereal aisle instead of online. It might be such a refreshing change of pace that she may go out with you just for being brave enough to ask.

4 thoughts on “Pondering Pick-Ups

  1. Simon says:

    This is probably just a British thing, but if you’re in the supermarket and you say something to a woman about melons, you’re likely to be slapped or arrested; or both.


    “Those are nice melons.” – Factually correct, but can be misconstrued as: “I’ve just been looking at your breasts and I think they’re splendid.”
    Or: “Those are the biggest melons I’ve ever seen.” – same problem, see above.

  2. TheresaMC says:

    I was going for a little double entendre…plus if a girl laughs at your cheesy pickup line at least you’ll know she’s got a sense of humor.

  3. Simon says:

    If a girl laughed at any of my cheesy chat up lines, she wouldn’t be the kind of girl I would want to go out with. Ah, but, if the poor, unsuspecting….if the girl was to respond with something along the lines of, “You’re an idiot” then she would be the kind of girl to tickle my fancy. I don’t mean I have any time for the old tactic of ‘play hard to get’, because that’s just boring; I mean I can only respect someone if they’re honest and they’re an excellent judge of character.

    A friend of mine told me he’d signed up with match.com. You’ve met him, or people like him. His technique has always been to use the same chat-up line on about fifty girls in a night – his faith in the laws of probability has often been rewarded. He now does the same thing online. Creeeeepy.
    Not that I have anything against online dating. I don’t like filling out forms; and I’m not convinced it’s as effective a time management tool as is often suggested, but I suppose it’s safe to assume the people on there are there for the same reasons. Oh, apart from people like another friend of mine, who uses dating sites to find girls with whom he can cheat on his girlfriend.

    No change then.

  4. Jennifer Sommer says:

    You’re right. People don’t seem to traditionally date as much anymore or go with the traditional ask out. Guys tend to ask girls to hang out over text message, etc. It’s actually rather refreshing when one of them calls you up to schedule a date or asks in person.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s